| 2023 – Todd W. Logsdon | 1945 – Harry Eisel | 1917, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1897 4th Qtr. – William H. Crump |
| 2022 – Todd W. Logsdon | 1944 – Harry Eisel | 1916, 4th Qtr. – Bernard Hughes | 1897 3rd Qtr. – William T. Kirby |
| 2021 – Todd W. Logsdon | 1943 – Arch A. Baker | 1916 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1897, 2nd Qtr. – James Sambaugh |
| 2020 – William H. Price | 1942 – Woodrow Layman | 1916, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1897, 1st Qtr. – Maxwell Hamilton |
| 2019 – William H. Price | 1941 – Bernard Hughes | 1916, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1896 4th Qtr. – Maxwell Hamilton |
| 2018 – William H. Price | 1940 – Bernard Hughes | 1915, 4th Qtr. – George Mayer | 1896 3rd Qtr. – Maxwell Hamilton |
| 2017 – John Jarvis | 1939 – Charles Dillon | 1915 3rd Qtr. – George Mayer | 1896, 2nd Qtr. – William H. Crump |
| 2016 – Todd W. Logsdon | 1938 – Charles Dillon | 1915, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1896, 1st Qtr.- George Lemmert |
| 2015 – Ronald W. Dugan | 1937 – Charles Dillon | 1915, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1895 4th Qtr. – Frednek Domdera |
| 2014 – William H. Price | 1936 – Charles Dillon | 1914, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1895 3rd Qtr. – Owen E. Dando |
| 2013 – Gary E. Tummino | 1935 – John D. Keller | 1914 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1895, 2nd Qtr. – T.S. Preston |
| 2012 – Gary E. Tummino | 1934 – John D. Keller | 1914, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1895, 1st Qtr. – Charles H. Hamill |
| 2011 – Gary E. Tummino | 1933, 4th Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1914, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1894 4th Qtr. – Charles H. Hamill |
| 2010 – Joseph Brumage | 1933, 3rd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1913, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1894 3rd Qtr. – Charles H. Hamill |
| 2009 – Joseph Brumage | 1933, 2nd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1913 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1894, 2nd Qtr. – John O. Evans |
| 2008 – Harry Wolford | 1933, 1st Qtr.- John D. Keller | 1913, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1894, 1st Qtr. – John O. Evans |
| 2007 – Harry Wolford | 1932 4th Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1913, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1893 4th Qtr. – William H. Crump |
| 2006 – Joseph Brumage | 1932, 3rd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1912, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1893 3rd Qtr. – Thomas S. Dillon |
| 2005 – Jay Dudley | 1932, 2nd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1912 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1893, 2nd Qtr. – Thomas S. Dillon |
| 2004 – Harry Wolford | 1932, 1st Qtr.- John D. Keller | 1912, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1893, 1st Qtr. – Henry Fischer |
| 2003 – Harry Wolford | 1931, 4th Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1912, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1892 4th Qtr. – Benjamin Carson |
| 2002 – Harry Wolford | 1931, 3rd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1911, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1892 3rd Qtr. – David K. Smith |
| 2001 – Harry Wolford | 1931, 2nd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1911 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1892, 2nd Qtr. – Frank Winner |
| 2000 – Harry Wolford | 1931, 1st Qtr.- John D. Keller | 1911, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1892, 1st Qtr. – John O. Evans |
| 1999 – Harry Wolford | 1930, 4th Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1911, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1891 4th Qtr. – August Eichorn |
| 1998 – Joseph Brumage | 1930, 3rd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1910, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1891 3rd Qtr. – William R. Gunter |
| 1997 – Joseph Brumage | 1930, 2nd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1910 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1891, 2nd Qtr. – Owen E. Dando |
| 1996 – Joe Brumage | 1930, 1st Qtr.- John D. Keller | 1910, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1891, 1st Qtr. – John F. Workman |
| 1995 – Joseph Brumage | 1929, 4th Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1910, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1890 4th Qtr. – John F. Workman |
| 1994 – Joseph Brumage | 1929, 3rd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1909, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1890 3rd Qtr. – Frank Winner |
| 1993 – Harry Wolford | 1929, 2nd Qtr. – William Walkler | 1909 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1890, 2nd Qtr. – Alexander Smith |
| 1992 – Harry Wolford | 1929, 1st Qtr.- James Jeffries | 1909, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1890, 1st Qtr. – John H. Bath |
| 1991 – Harry Wolford | 1928, 4th Qtr. – James Jeffries | 1909, 1st Qtr.- William Wink | 1889 4th Qtr. – John H. Bath |
| 1990 – Harry Wolford | 1928, 3rd Qtr. – James Jeffries | 1908, 4th Qtr. – Alfred Jeffries | 1889 3rd Qtr. – John F. Workman |
| 1989 – Harry Wolford | 1928, 2nd Qtr. – Edward Bevans | 1908 3rd Qtr. – Alfred Jeffries | 1889, 2nd Qtr. – Owen E. Dando |
| 1988 – Gary E. Tummino | 1928, 1st Qtr.- Edward Bevans | 1908, 2nd Qtr. – Alfred Jeffries | 1889, 1st Qtr. – J.B. Carson |
| 1987 – Nevin Montana | 1927, 4th Qtr. – Edward Bevans | 1908, 1st Qtr.- Alfred Jeffries | 1888 4th Qtr. – J.B. Carson |
| 1986 – Nevin Montana | 1927, 3rd Qtr. – John T. Hart | 1907, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1888 3rd Qtr. – John H. Bath |
| 1985 – Harry Wolford | 1927, 1st Qtr.- James Jeffries | 1907 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1888, 2nd Qtr. – Palmer Sperry |
| 1984 – Harry Wolford | 1926, 4th Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1907, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1888, 1st Qtr. – John H. Bath |
| 1983 – Robert L. Dugan, Jr. | 1926, 3rd Qtr. – Arch A. Baker | 1907, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1887 4th Qtr. – William Arnold |
| 1982 – E. Michael Shirley | 1926, 2nd Qtr. – Charles Stark | 1906, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1887 3rd Qtr. – J.B. Carson |
| 1981 – E. Michael Shirley | 1926, 1st Qtr. – Elmer Kight | 1906 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1887, 2nd Qtr. – J.B. Carson |
| 1980 – E. Michael Shirley | 1925, 4th Qtr. – Elmer Kight | 1906, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1887, 1st Qtr. – J.B. Carson |
| 1979 – Robert Connor | 1925, 3rd Qtr. – Elmer Kight | 1906, 1st Qtr.- Walter W. Wittig | 1886 4th Qtr. – J.B. Carson |
| 1978 – Robert Connor | 1925, 1st Qtr.- Elmer Kight | 1905, 4th Qtr. – Walter W. Wittig | 1886 3rd Qtr. – J.B. Carson |
| 1977 – Robert Connor | 1924, 4th Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1905, 3rd Qtr. – Frank Spates | 1886, 2nd Qtr. – John F. Workman |
| 1976 – Michael Grable | 1924, 3rd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1905, 2nd Qtr. – Joseph Baer | 1886, 1st Qtr. – John F. Workman |
| 1975 – Donald Davis | 1924, 2nd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1905, 1st Qtr.- Joseph Baer | 1885 4th Qtr. – William H. Crump |
| 1974 – Donald Davis | 1924, 1st Qtr.- John D. Keller | 1904, 4th Qtr. – Joseph Baer | 1885 3rd Qtr. – Frank Spates |
| 1973 – Donald Davis | 1923, 4th Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1904 3rd Qtr. – Thomas G. Dillon | 1885, 2nd Qtr. – N/A |
| 1972 – Donald Davis | 1923, 3rd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1904, 2nd Qtr. – Thomas G. Dillon | 1885, 1st Qtr. – N/A |
| 1971 – Donald Davis | 1923, 2nd Qtr. – John D. Keller | 1904, 1st Qtr.- Thomas G. Dillon | 1884 4th Qtr. – N/A |
| 1970 – Donald Davis | 1923, 1st Qtr.- Charles Stark | 1903, 4th Qtr. – Thomas G. Dillon | 1884 3rd Qtr. – Maxwell Hamilton |
| 1969 – Donald Davis | 1922, 4th Qtr. – Elmer Kight | 1903 3rd Qtr. – William T. Kirby | 1884, 2nd Qtr. – N/A |
| 1968 – Michael Grable | 1922, 3rd Qtr. – Elmer Kight | 1903, 2nd Qtr. – John T. Hart | 1884, 1st Qtr. – N/A |
| 1967 – Michael Grable | 1922, 2nd Qtr. – Elmer Kight | 1903, 1st Qtr.- William Griffith | 1883 4th Qtr. – N/A |
| 1966 – Michael Grable | 1922, 1st Qtr.- Elmer Kight | 1902, 4th Qtr. – William W. Wittig | 1883 3rd Qtr. – William H. Crump |
| 1965 – Michael Grable | 1921, 4th Qtr. – Olin Gunnett | 1902 3rd Qtr. – William W. Wittig | 1883, 2nd Qtr. – N/A |
| 1964 – Michael Grable | 1921, 3rd Qtr. – Olin Gunnett | 1902, 2nd Qtr. – William W. Wittig | 1883, 1st Qtr.- N/A |
| 1963 – Donald D. Greig | 1921, 2nd Qtr. – Olin Gunnett | 1902, 1st Qtr.- John O. Evans | 1882 4th Qtr. – N/A |
| 1962 – James M. McMorran | 1921, 1st Qtr.- Olin Gunnett | 1901, 4th Qtr. – John T. Hart | 1882 3rd Qtr. – Charles M. Taylor |
| 1961 – William Close | 1920, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1901 3rd Qtr. – John T. Hart | 1882, 2nd Qtr. – Peter Whetstone |
| 1960 – William Close | 1920, 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1901, 2nd Qtr. – John T. Hart | 1882, 1st Qtr.- N/A |
| 1959 – David H. Powell | 1920, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1901, 1st Qtr.- David K. Smith | 1881 4th Qtr. – N/A |
| 1958 – David H. Powell | 1920, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1900, 4th Qtr. – Frank Spates | 1881 3rd Qtr. – N/A |
| 1957 – David H. Powell | 1919, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1900 3rd Qtr. – George Mayer | 1881, 2nd Qtr. – N/A |
| 1956 – Ritchie Middleton | 1919 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1900, 2nd Qtr. – George Mayer | 1881, 1st Qtr.- Richard K. Mason |
| 1955 – Paul C. Haberlein | 1919, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1900, 1st Qtr.- Henry Brode | 1880 4th Qtr. – Richard K. Mason |
| 1954 – Paul C. Haberlein | 1919, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1899, 4th Qtr. – Charles H. Hamill | 1880 3rd Qtr. – Charles M. Taylor |
| 1953 – Paul C. Haberlein | 1918, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1899 3rd Qtr. – Walter W. Wittig | 1880, 2nd Qtr. – Daniel Scally |
| 1952 – Paul C. Haberlein | 1918 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1899, 2nd Qtr. – Maxwell Hamilton | 1880, 1st Qtr.- Benjamin Bowen |
| 1951 – Paul C. Haberlein | 1918, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1899, 1st Qtr.- Owen E. Dando | 1879 4th Qtr. – Charles M. Taylor |
| 1950 – Florian Nickel | 1918, 1st Qtr.- N/A | 1898 4th Qtr. – Owen E. Dando | 1879 3rd Qtr. – Richard K. Mason |
| 1949 – Florian Nickel | 1917, 4th Qtr. – N/A | 1898 3rd Qtr. – William H. Crump | 1879, 2nd Qtr. – Benjamin Bowen |
| 1948 – John D. Keller | 1917 3rd Qtr. – N/A | 1898, 2nd Qtr. – Henry Brode | 1879, 1st Qtr.- Benjamin Bowen |
| 1947 – John D. Keller | 1917, 2nd Qtr. – N/A | 1898, 1st Qtr.- William H. Crump | 1878 – George B. McCulloh |
| 1946 – Jesse F. Jacobs | | | |
